Visit the Naim E-Store
Naim Audio Main Website    forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Naim Users  Hop To Forums  Hi-Fi Corner    3.5+flatcap vs. Cdi

Closed Topic Closed
Go
New
Find
Tools
  Login/Join 
1st Timer
Posted
I have opportunity to buy s/h CDI for almost
negliable price if i sell my 3.5. So what differencies in sound? Detail,timing,soundstage,PRaT.

system 3.5/flatcap/nait3/kann2

 
Posts: 2 | Location: FINLAND | Registered: Fri 25 August 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Member
Posted Hide Post
It could be difficult clearing out before you have both in house for a listening test.

I've had CDI, in my system it was harsh and coarse, but with tremendous nearness, authority and weight. I've later learnt of members that it's a must to get a topclass stand for it.

I've downgraded to a CD3, it wasn't as coarse and harsh, but it has a somehow "thinner presentation". It is possible to be swept away in music on both CD's, but I miss something the CDI could, therefore I'm searching for a s/h CD2/CDX/CDS1.

Also think of the lifetime of the laser, as the CD3.5 must be some years younger.

Best regards
Per

 
Posts: 472 | Location: Denmark | Registered: Wed 25 October 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Senior Member
Posted Hide Post
Per is right, the CDI needs a good quality support, mine was elevated from "musical, but a little harsh and coarse" to "musical, lively, and authorative".
I have only heard a 3.5 in poor conditions. I do like, though, late CD3's such as I had. They are also less sensitive to setup.

I would only make this swap after listening to the CDI, preferably well set-up.

 
Posts: 1044 | Location: Tel-Aviv, Israel. | Registered: Tue 01 August 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Vik
Trade Member
Posted Hide Post
Completely with Omie, especially on latter day CD3.0s.

Except that I would not swop. :-)

The CDI is just more correct, but NEEDS a good support. Think of it as a Naim CDP with a built in Hicap.

Older CDIs with the CDM4 mechs are better than those with CDM9-pro mechs.

While you're at it, maybe you could ditch the 3.5 and move the Flatcap to the Nait?

 
Posts: 339 | Location: Cincinnati, OH | Registered: Thu 17 August 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
1st Timer
Posted Hide Post
The laser mech of CDi is changed within a year.
Is it then cdm9pro or cdm4? I have five tier target rack with spiked top shelf.
 
Posts: 2 | Location: FINLAND | Registered: Fri 25 August 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Vik
Trade Member
Posted Hide Post
the 9pro protrudes somewhat whilst the 4 is flushed flat, like the rest of the immediate surrounding area.

happy new year

 
Posts: 339 | Location: Cincinnati, OH | Registered: Thu 17 August 2000Edit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community  

Closed Topic Closed

Naim Audio Main Website    forums  Hop To Forum Categories  Naim Users  Hop To Forums  Hi-Fi Corner    3.5+flatcap vs. Cdi

© Naim Audio Ltd, 2006.